McKillop Mutual is a progressive P&C Mutual Insurance Company located in Seaforth, Ontario.  We have a rich history of providing personal, agricultural and commercial insurance products through a dedicated team of agents and independent insurance brokers.

We currently have an exciting career opportunity for a permanent full time Underwriter.

 As an Underwriter, you will:

  • Possess effective team building skills with a passion to share knowledge and build relationships with agents, broker and the underwriting team.
  • Exhibit sound judgment and confident decision making skills.
  • Assess risks to determine eligibility, exposure and ensure proper classification and rating.
  • Consistently strive for sustainable, profitable business through your actions and decisions.
  • Strong computer skills and the ability to adapt to changes in technology, processes and workflow.


  • Post-secondary education.
  • CIP designation or working towards one.
  • Minimum of 5 years of underwriting experience (knowledge of commercial and farm would be considered an asset).
  • Excellent verbal and written communication, superior customer service skills, excellent time management with the ability to multi-task.
  • Proficient computer applications including Microsoft Office.

We offer a competitive compensation, benefits and pension plan and provide a business casual environment that supports a healthy work-life balance.  Due to COVID restrictions working from home is currently an option.  If you are interested in this position, please submit a resume and covering letter to:


McKillop Mutual Insurance Company

Attention: Tracy Lamont

Box 819, 91 Main St. S.,

Seaforth, ON   N0K 1W0

Or email tracy@mckillopmutual.com


Deadline for applications is May 1, 2021


We thank all applicants for their interest.  Only those considered for an interview will be contacted.